The HNI Dilemma

Mahesh Pai explains why a lack of liquidity planning leaves many HNIs asset-rich and cash-poor

For many High Net-Worth Individuals (HNIs), wealth creation has always meant buying assets like real estate, gold, luxury cars, or simply reinvesting into the business. These symbols of success look impressive on balance sheets and in conversations. Yet when liquidity is required, whether an emergency, a strategic investment, or even a lifestyle expense; many discover that they are unprepared.
This is the paradox of being asset-rich but cash-poor, owning plenty on paper, but lacking liquidity when it matters most.
The asset obsession among HNIs
HNIs naturally gravitate toward assets that symbolize stability and prestige. Real estate portfolios are built across cities, gold is accumulated as a family legacy, and high-end cars are financed without a second thought.
But here’s the reality:
• Properties are illiquid: you can’t unlock part of a `20 crore apartment when an urgent opportunity arises.
• Gold is a prestige: Only a few HNIs would consider liquidating family gold for everyday cash flow.
• EMIs on luxury homes and cars drain monthly liquidity, often without generating proportional income.
The outcome? Many HNIs look wealthy externally but feel constant pressure internally due to poor liquidity planning.
The EMI Trap at the HNI Level
HNIs, too, fall into the EMI culture, except the numbers are larger and the stakes are higher. Expensive homes, luxury cars, and holiday properties often come with structured loans. Servicing these EMIs can consume a surprising portion of monthly income, leaving less flexibility for:
• Immediate liquidity needs
• Opportunistic investments
• Expanding existing businesses.
A common HNI example
Consider a 45-year-old entrepreneur in Delhi. On paper, his balance sheet is enviable:
• Four properties – two luxury residences, one commercial space, one holiday villa.
• Luxury cars, financed through EMIs.
• Over `1 crore in gold accumulated over generations.
Yet when a promising investment opportunity in a fast-scaling startup came his way, he had to pass, not because he lacked wealth but because he lacked liquidity. Despite holding assets worth several crores, he had less than `15 lakh readily available.This is the classic definition of being asset-rich, cash-poor – a situation no HNI should be in.
Gold: Prestige over Practicality
For HNIs, gold is less about liquidity and more about legacy. It symbolises prosperity, social standing, and cultural continuity. Liquidating gold for cash flow is often unthinkable; it signals distress rather than strategy.
But this also means that a significant portion of wealth sits idle, failing to contribute to liquidity or income.
Fixed Deposits: A false comfort
When HNIs do set aside cash, it often ends up in fixed deposits. The problem? FDs are a poor tool for wealth preservation. At 6% interest, taxed at 30% and adjusted for 6% inflation, the real rate of return is negative. For HNIs, whose portfolios need to outpace inflation by a wide margin, parking crores in FDs is effectively a slow leak of wealth.
FDs might appear liquid, but in reality, they are a trap offering access to cash at the cost of eroded purchasing power.
The missing link: Liquidity planning for HNIs
True wealth management isn’t just about accumulating assets but rather it’s about structuring liquidity intelligently. Without liquidity planning, even the wealthiest balance sheet can create financial stress.
For HNIs, liquidity planning involves:
• Dedicated liquidity reserves in short-term, tax-efficient instruments (liquid funds, money market funds, ultra-short debt funds).
• Income-generating allocations: dividend-paying equities, rental yield strategies, or alternative investments that provide regular cash flow.
• Prudent use of leverage: avoiding overexposure to EMIs that choke monthly liquidity.
• Segregating opportunity capital: a reserve specifically for high-return, time-sensitive opportunities like startup funding or distressed asset buys.
Asset-Rich vs. Truly Wealthy
There is a key distinction between being ‘asset-rich’ and being truly wealthy.
• Asset-rich HNIs: Own multiple properties, luxury assets, and gold, but lack liquidity to handle crises or capitalise on opportunities.
• Truly wealthy HNIs: Maintain the right balance of prestige assets and accessible cash flow. They never have to sell an asset in distress, nor do they miss opportunities due to lack of liquidity.
Without liquidity, wealth can feel like a burden instead of a tool. HNIs who ignore liquidity, risk being trapped and appear wealthy on paper, but unable to act when it matters most. In today’s world, the hallmark of true financial sophistication is not just having assets – it is having cash flow, liquidity, and ability to move quickly
The writer is an investment consultant and business coach. Email: mahesh@maheshpai.in

Mobile Ad 1

Mobile Ad 2